Beneath the surface of steady consumer spending, a growing disconnect with record-low confidence reveals an American consumer stretched thin by inflation.
Back
US Retail Sales Rise 0.5% in April as Gas Prices Mask Consumer Strain
U.S. retail sales rose 0.5% in April, a headline number that met economist forecasts but was largely inflated by a sharp increase in gasoline prices, masking underlying weakness in consumer demand amid persistent inflation. The data, which followed a downwardly revised 1.6% jump in March, shows a consumer that is still spending but getting less for their money.
"Consumers are drawing down tax refunds more rapidly than last year, particularly among lower-income households," economists at PNC Financial said in a note, citing an analysis of internal data that shows less of those refunds are being used to pay down credit card and other debt.
Sales at gasoline stations jumped 2.8% in April, according to the Commerce Department report, a direct consequence of the Iran war pushing energy prices higher. Excluding the volatile gas component, retail sales were up a more modest 0.3%, a significant slowdown from March's 0.7% pace, excluding gas. With the government reporting earlier in the week that consumer prices rose 0.6% in April, real spending adjusted for inflation likely declined for the month.
The data presents a complex puzzle for the Federal Reserve. While resilient nominal spending could justify a continued hawkish stance against inflation, the divergence with consumer sentiment, which has plunged to record lows, suggests the pressure from high prices could trigger a sharp pullback in spending in the coming months.
The Great Disconnect
The most striking feature of the current economic landscape is the widening chasm between consumer sentiment and actual spending. The University of Michigan's consumer sentiment index has fallen to a historic low, yet retail sales data shows households continue to spend, for now. This divergence has led some economists to question the predictive power of sentiment surveys, while others see it as a warning sign of a spending cliff to come.
The April report showed unevenness across sectors. While online retailers saw a 1.1% increase and electronics stores posted a 1.4% gain, other areas showed strain. Sales at department stores fell 3.2%, and furniture and home furnishings stores saw a 2% slip. This pattern suggests consumers are prioritizing necessities and some goods while cutting back on discretionary items and big-ticket purchases. The lone services category in the report, restaurants, saw a modest 0.6% increase, a potential sign that higher gas prices are leaving less room in budgets for dining out.
This dynamic is occurring against a backdrop of a surprisingly strong labor market, which added 115,000 jobs in April, and larger tax refunds that provided a temporary cushion to household finances. However, that cushion is diminishing. With inflation outpacing wage growth for the first time in three years, the purchasing power of American households is eroding.
The durability of consumer spending will be critical for economic growth in the second quarter. Core retail sales, which correspond most closely with the consumer spending component of GDP, rose 0.5% in April. This, combined with an upward revision to the March data, may lead economists to revise up their Q2 GDP forecasts. Yet, if stubborn inflation and high gas prices persist, the resilience that has defined the U.S. consumer could finally begin to fracture.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
[1] US April Retail Sales Hit 8-Month High, But Consumer Confidence Drops to Historic Low[2] U.S. retail sales increase again, but higher gas prices and inflation played a big role[3] Retail sales growth slowed in April from March as higher gas cost leaves less room for nonessentials[4] US retail sales increase again in April, partly lifted by higher prices[5] The Week Ahead: US CPI and Retail Sales, China Inflation, and Trump-Xi Talks |...
