With markets entrenched in a "stagflation trade," the upcoming US jobs report, expecting a modest 65,000 gain, is unlikely to revive hopes for a Federal Reserve rate cut this year.
Back
Back
US jobs data: why 65k new roles may not move the Fed
The US labor market is poised to show a significant slowdown with the release of April's non-farm payrolls data, but it may do little to alter the Federal Reserve's hawkish stance. Consensus estimates forecast the creation of just 65,000 jobs, a sharp drop from the 178,000 added in March, as the market braces for data that could reinforce a "higher-for-longer" interest rate narrative.
"To bring rate cuts back to the table, we would need to see the unemployment rate rise to 4.5% or clearly negative job growth, not just a single monthly report that is weaker than expected," said Brandon Brown of Goldman Sachs' interest rate trading desk.
The forecast for the April data, due at 8:30 p.m. Beijing time, is marked by significant divergence. Estimates range from a high of 133,000 new jobs from Sough Bay Research to a potential loss of 15,000 jobs predicted by Citigroup. This wide dispersion stems from analysts attempting to parse the statistical noise from March, including the reversal of temporary factors like weather and strike-related employment boosts.
The core issue for investors is that the Federal Reserve's focus has decisively shifted from employment to inflation, particularly with oil prices rising due to Middle East conflicts. A strong jobs number could accelerate the "stagflation trade," solidifying expectations of a prolonged pause and even re-introducing a non-zero probability of a rate hike, which would likely push US Treasury yields higher.
Divergent Forecasts and Technical Factors
Major Wall Street institutions reflect the broad uncertainty. Goldman Sachs is forecasting 75,000 new jobs, slightly above consensus, while JPMorgan Chase expects a more modest 50,000. Bank of America holds the most optimistic view among major banks at 80,000. The core of the disagreement lies in interpreting the volatility of recent months, with private payrolls swinging from +180,000 to -129,000 and then back to +186,000 over the last quarter.
High-frequency indicators offer conflicting signals. The April ADP private employment report showed 109,000 jobs added, below the 120,000 consensus. However, Pantheon Macroeconomics noted the report's average absolute forecast error over the past year is a substantial 85,000, urging caution in its interpretation.
A Labor Market Divided
Beneath the headline number, the labor market shows signs of a deepening "K-shaped" divergence. According to Bank of America, the top third of earners saw their after-tax wages grow by 6% in April, while the bottom third saw only a 1.5% increase — a net loss in real income when measured against the 3.5% rise in the consumer price index.
This split is also visible across industries. The ISM Manufacturing employment index fell to 46.4 in April, its 31st consecutive month of contraction. While the services employment index improved to 48.0, it remains in contraction territory. New York Fed President John Williams acknowledged these "conflicting signals" between hard data and surveys this week, describing the current environment as a "low-hire, low-fire" labor market.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
[1] "Stagflation trade" sweeps the market, how bad does tonight's NFP have to be to restart rate cut expectations?[2] Nonfarm payrolls expected to subside closer to equilibrium in April[3] Japanese Yen flat lines on suspected intervention, US NFP data in focus[4] German Industrial Production falls 0.7% MoM in March vs. 0.5% expected[5] USD/JPY recovery stalls below 157.00 as intervention risks linger
