Key Takeaways:
- Market-timers exited US equities at a near-unprecedented pace on May 28
- The extreme bearish positioning triggered a rare contrarian buy signal
- S&P 500 sits near record highs, up almost 10% year to date
Back
S&P 500 flashes rare buy signal as market-timers flee at record pace
Market-timers ran for the exits at a pace that has historically marked a buying opportunity for US equities.
The S&P 500 rose 0.33% to 7,569.60 on Thursday, extending a rally that has pushed the benchmark index up almost 10% this year. The move came as a measure of market-timer positioning showed bearish bets at levels that have preceded short-term rallies in each of the past five instances since 2022.
"The speed and magnitude of the positioning unwind is what catches our attention — it's the kind of capitulation that typically marks a near-term floor," said Lori Calvasina, head of US equity strategy at RBC Capital Markets. "When everyone is already positioned for a decline, there's little fuel left to drive one."
The Dow Jones Industrial Average slipped 0.27% to 50,617.00, while the Nasdaq Composite added 0.63% to close at 30,260.90. All three major indexes had finished at record highs together on Wednesday for the first time since October 2025, according to Dow Jones Market Data. The Cboe Volatility Index held near 15, well below its 12-month average, suggesting complacency among options traders even as equity positioning turned defensive.
The contrarian signal emerges against a backdrop of conflicting crosscurrents. The S&P 500's rally has been powered almost entirely by artificial intelligence-related spending, with Nvidia posting 85% revenue growth to $81.6 billion in its most recent quarter and Alphabet's operating income rising 30% year over year to $40 billion. The 10-year Treasury yield edged lower by 3 basis points to 4.32%, while the dollar index slipped 0.2%, providing a tailwind for equities.
Why the Signal Matters Now
Consumer sentiment has deteriorated to levels below the 2022 inflation peak, dragged by rising gasoline and food prices as inflation reaccelerates. That divergence — record stock prices alongside weakening consumer confidence — has fueled the bearish positioning that contrarians now see as a setup for further gains.
"The market is pricing a $700 billion infrastructure build-out from the big compute providers, and that spending is locked in regardless of what consumer sentiment data says," Calvasina said. "The question is whether that's enough to sustain the rally through the second half."
Traders are watching for confirmation from the AI earnings pipeline, with major cloud providers expected to report data center utilization rates in coming weeks. The next catalyst for direction could come from May payrolls data due June 5, which will test whether the labor market can absorb higher borrowing costs without cracking.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
[1] This overvalued stock market just flashed a rare buy signal[2] Trump Invested in Intel And it Soared 500%. Here’s the Next Industry the Government is Buying.[3] What the First-Quarter Earnings Season Is Really Telling Us About 2026[4] Stocks just scored a trifecta of record closes for the first time in 2026. What to expect next.
