J.M. Smucker Raises Coffee Prices Amid Persistent Tariffs and Supply Pressures

Opening

J.M. Smucker Company (SJM) is poised to implement a third coffee price increase this year, driven by persistent inflationary pressures and elevated tariffs on green coffee imports. This move is projected to result in an overall price escalation exceeding 20% compared to the prior year, as the company navigates a complex global supply environment.

The Event in Detail

The latest price adjustment, anticipated for "early winter," follows previous hikes in May and August. These measures are a direct response to a confluence of factors, including rising sourcing costs and the significant impact of U.S. tariffs on coffee imports from key producing nations. Specifically, imports from Brazil face a 50% tariff, while those from Vietnam incur a 20% tariff. These tariffs have contributed to a nearly 21% year-over-year increase in consumer coffee costs, as reported by the August Consumer Price Index. J.M. Smucker sources approximately 500 million pounds of unroasted coffee beans annually from these two countries, making it highly susceptible to these import duties. The global coffee market itself has seen arabica and robusta futures reach multi-year highs in 2025, exacerbated by a lingering drought in Brazil and poor crop conditions in Vietnam.

Analysis of Market Reaction

Despite the potential for dampened coffee sales volume, J.M. Smucker anticipates generating an additional $100 million in revenue during the current fiscal year from these pricing strategies. The company's management expresses confidence in the resilience of the at-home coffee category, citing consumers' ingrained daily rituals. CFO Tucker Marshall noted that earlier price elasticity trends have been "favorable to our initial expectations," underscoring the strength of their brand portfolio. However, the consistent price increases by J.M. Smucker and other importers have translated into a 20.9% year-over-year increase in U.S. retail coffee prices as of August, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Broader Context & Implications

This impending price hike marks the fifth such increase by J.M. Smucker since June 2024. The company's U.S. retail coffee division has already experienced a 22% year-on-year plunge in profit due to elevated input costs stemming from the 50% tariff on Brazilian green coffee. This scenario forces roasters to either absorb higher costs, pass them on to consumers, or seek alternative, though often limited, sourcing options. The overall impact extends beyond J.M. Smucker, with industry warnings of potential "demand destruction." Rabobank projects a 0.5% decline in global coffee consumption for 2025, largely attributed to these higher prices. While at-home consumption surged during the pandemic, it has since softened. Competitors such as Keurig Dr Pepper have also faced challenges, with its U.S. coffee segment volume falling more than 5% in early 2025. Starbucks, in contrast, has leveraged its brand strength and café formats to more smoothly pass through increased costs.

Expert Commentary

Marc Schonland, Strategic Adviser to the coffee industry, highlights the foundational role Brazil plays in coffee blends due to its cost-effectiveness and consistent supply. He states:

"But a 50% tariff has upended that original purchase rationale, adding roughly $1.50 per pound and instantly erasing its price advantage. Roasters are being forced to cut back on Brazilian usage, but there's no single substitute for the roughly 8 million bags the US typically imports. Substitution will happen, but solutions will differ." KPMG Chief Economist Diane Swonk has cautioned that sustained coffee prices could easily surpass historical records if the full effects of the Brazilian tariffs continue to permeate the market.

Looking Ahead

Looking forward, J.M. Smucker faces continued pressure from elevated commodity costs, with the International Coffee Organization forecasting a 12% price increase for green coffee in 2026. The company's full-year guidance for Fiscal Year 2026 projects adjusted earnings per share between $8.50 and $9.50, representing a 10% to 15% decline from Fiscal Year 2025's $10.15 range. This outlook hinges on the successful execution of its pricing and sourcing strategies, alongside a gradual normalization of green coffee prices. However, analysts express concern about a potential tipping point where further price hikes could significantly dampen consumer demand, potentially driving them towards private-label alternatives and impacting J.M. Smucker's market share.